Robyn Flipse: The Coke-Funded Dietitian Threatening CrossFit Gyms

Yesterday, CrossFit’s twitter account linked to an op-ed entitled EDITORIAL: New Jersey trying to make dietary advice illegal. Dietitians were quick to respond, criticizing both CrossFit and free speech in nutrition.

One of those angry dietitians stood out: Robyn Flipse. The New Jersey-based dietitian issued an implicit threat:

“Gyms dispensing misinformation about diet have a lot to lose if the licensure bill passes.”

It is true that gyms that give dietary information “have a lot to lose” if states make this speech illegal. That is exactly why CrossFit Inc. is fighting against nutrition licensure in New Jersey and elsewhere. But what do Robyn Flipse and her fellow dietitians consider “misinformation”?

flipse_CCC_youtube.png

If someone recommended Coca-Cola as a healthy snack, is that misinformation? Not according to Flipse. She did so herself. As the Associated Press reported:

Robyn Flipse, the dietitian who wrote the sponsored article for Coke, said she would suggest mini-cans of Coke even if she wasn’t being paid.”

Nor was that a one-off transaction. Internal Coca-Cola emails recently acquired by CrossFit show that the Atlanta-based Kellen Company is leveraging Flipse’s dietetic credentials to defend soda on behalf of the soda industry. More on Kellen later.

flipse_kellen.png

In case there was any doubt, Coca-Cola’s website identifies Ms. Flipse as one of its “paid consultants.” And RobynFlipse.com lists the numerous companies and trade groups with whom she has worked. The full accounting of her 60+ corporations and association partners includes PepsiCo (through Frito-Lay, Sabra and other brands), Keebler, Dove Chocolate, the American Beverage Association, Monsanto, the Corn Refiners Association, the National Confectioners Association, and many, many others.

As part of her service to the Coca-Cola company, Flipse publicly opposes soda taxes, arguing, “When stores pay soda taxes we all cover those costs in higher prices for our groceries.”

So Flipse opposes government intervention when it comes to limiting soda consumption. Yet she supports it when it punishes fitness trainers for giving nutrition advice. What might explain this discrepancy?

Promoting soda and sugar as health food clearly counts as acceptable, accurate nutrition advice in Flipse’s book. So, what type of nutrition advice does Flipse label “misinformation”? Would she, for example, object to CrossFit’s recommendation to “eat meat and vegetables, nuts and seeds, some fruit, little starch and no sugar”?

Early this year the New Jersey Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (NJAND) had Flipse speak on “Food Cults.” Two of her slides criticized “paramilitary-style fitness regimes” and featured screenshots of the CrossFit website and a Paleo Diet book. The implication is clear: CrossFit affiliates and the Paleo Diet are scary cults. Beware!

betterbody_flipse.png

Just like the NSCA and ACSM, dietitians like Flipse engage in fear-mongering tactics with regard to CrossFit affiliates in an attempt to justify anti-competitive regulation. They do not want to directly compete with CrossFit at making people fitter and healthier. Instead, they resort to myths and lobbying.

Back to the Kellen Company, which employs Flipse on the scientific advisory board of its Calorie Control Council. Kellen also runs the Coalition for the Registration of Exercise Professionals (CREP) and its U.S. Registry of Exercise Professionals (USREPS). This is the ACSM- and NSCA-backed organization that lobbies for occupational licensure in the fitness industry. Many of these fitness licensure laws would make CrossFit’s affiliate model illegal. Fortunately, CrossFit has successfully prevented fitness licensure from taking hold anywhere in the U.S.

Nutrition licensure laws, however, remain in effect in some U.S. states. These laws have been used to punish CrossFit trainers and affiliates such as Heather Kokesch Del Castillo. The state of Florida conducted an undercover sting operation, then fined and threatened Del Castillo with jail time, just for giving unlicensed nutrition advice. CrossFit is working to remove such senseless laws from the books. Heather is suing the state of Florida to defend her right to speak freely about food to individuals. You can read more about her case against the state of Florida by going to the Institute for Justice website.

It should not surprise anyone to see that the dietitians lobbying to restrict CrossFit affiliates are tied to the food and beverage industry. Who else would object to such basic, common-sense advice? The states that regulate nutrition speech most severely have the highest obesity and diabetes rates. In contrast, states such as New Jersey, New York and California, which regulate it the least, have much lower diabetes rates. No evidence shows that nutrition licensure improves public safety, nor that protecting free speech in nutrition increases the risk to consumers.

The nutrition advice that CrossFit affiliates and trainers provide is only a threat to the bottom line of Coca-Cola, PepsiCo, and the other junk-food companies, most of which seem to have funded Robyn Flipse, RD.

flipse_cheerios.png

6 comments

  1. It’s unbelievable the lengths to with some dietitians are willing to make a mockery of their profession by using their credentials to push absurd propaganda. I hope the money is good at least, if they keep this going they will become irrelevant!

  2. Karen Stefaniak Brennan

    I’m a cross fitter, board certified holistic nutritionist and I used to live in NJ. Been following this and hope it doesn’t happen. The RD education is not the same as the holistic nutrition education and it would be a shame for people to miss out on the benefits provided by the holistic nutrition field. Just curious- top pic of Robyn, I’m hoping the foods in that pic are foods she’s not recommending! (Bottom pic not much better but at least has eggs and some fruit in it).

  3. Amanda Crooks

    This article infuriates me!!! I honestly don’t understand how Robyn Flipse and other RD’s funded by sugar companies can sleep at night with the lies they spew to the public. NOOO amount of money would make me do that! I know that’s easy for me to say, but my morals & values ALWAYS come before $$$. The food industry and big soda companies make me sick! Thank god for Crossfit fighting all of these legal battles and fighting to keep us all healthier!

  4. Dan Hope

    It seems the advice of medical doctors, the American Heart Association, the National Institute of Health, the Fedral Drug Administration and other supposedly educated and licensed organizations and professionals has made the United States one of the least healthy countries in the developed world. Will requiring licensure also mean authors like Gary Taub, Max Lugavere and others will have to have degrees in nutrition and be licensed? What about mothers, fathers, and grandparents? Surely they cannot know anything unless the are registered dieticians or nutritionists. What has become of critical thinking and one’s ability to do research and learn what is best for one? Certainly following the advice of licensed experts has led the U.S. down the wrong path.

    • Karen Stefaniak Brennan

      Dan, actually as a nutritionist with a certification, I also wouldn’t be able to give any nutritional advice. Only RD’s would be able to if this passes in NJ.

Leave a Reply to Timothy Matta Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: